Proposed Changes to Organic Labelling in Australia Spark Debate Among Producers and Government

57
2
Proposed Changes to Organic Labelling in Australia Spark Debate Among Producers and Government

Producers in Australia are advocating for changes to organic labelling laws, with a proposed National Organic Standard Bill currently being examined by a Senate committee. The bill, tabled by Nationals senator Bridget McKenzie, aims to regulate the sale of organic products within Australia, irrespective of their origin. Proponents of the bill argue that setting a national standard would provide full transparency to consumers and create a level playing field among organic producers.

Certified organic food business owner Tammie Phillips highlighted the lack of regulation in Australia, allowing room for deceptive practices like greenwashing by some producers. She emphasized the importance of regulation to prevent fraudulent operations and make it easier for consumers to identify and purchase certified organic produce. Similarly, South Australian organic vegetable grower Shane Eldridge expressed support for a national standard that would align producers and provide clarity to consumers.

According to Australian Organic Limited chief executive Jackie Brian, the absence of legal requirements for organic certification within Australia leads to potential misuse of the term "organic" on product labels. This loophole puts the burden on consumers to navigate through labels and verify the authenticity of organic products. Brian also pointed out that implementing the proposed regulation could not only prevent fraud and enhance consumer transparency but also unlock significant export opportunities for Australian organic producers.

Despite the potential benefits of a national organic standard, concerns have been raised regarding the costs associated with enforcing regulations and the possible impact on smaller organic producers. Former Labor Federal Agriculture Minister Murray Watt and the agriculture department have cited cost-benefit analyses suggesting that the costs of implementing mandatory regulation could outweigh the benefits. Additionally, there are worries that smaller organic producers may bear a disproportionate burden if such regulations are put in place.

While many submissions to the Senate inquiry have expressed support for a national organic standard, the government's stance remains undecided. Federal Agricultural Minister Julie Collins criticized the previous Liberal-Nationals government for failing to implement a national standard over nearly a decade, impacting trade relationships. The current government is yet to announce its position on the proposed changes, awaiting the findings of the Senate inquiry to carefully consider the implications of regulating organic labelling in Australia.